Haley's stepbrother, Nathan Bronson, is laying upstairs listening to the commotion. He finally can't take it anymore and comes downstairs to confront them. The girls instantly go for it, trying to tease and taunt Nathan into fucking them. Haley asks why Nathan can't be like one of the stepbrothers who's always putting his dick through things. That causes him to storm off back to his room, where he stays until Madi jumps onto his bed and tells him that he has to come quick and see what's going on.
Nathan finds Haley with the putting green against her pussy so that the golf hole outlines her lips. Nathan can't take it anymore! He whips it out and sinks it into his stepsister's coochie while Madi and Nadia take turns eating each other out beside them. Then the girls form a line of pleasure with Madi getting Nathan's cock in doggy while she eats out Haley, who in turn keeps Nadia's party rolling. Nadia finally gets her turn with the fuck stick as she takes a reverse cowgirl stiffie ride with her friends licking her nipples. The girls reward Nathan's hard work with a triple BJ, but Haley wants him to cum on her ass so he brings himself to his own finish line by doing his stepsis in doggy before obediently giving her the jizz right where she wants it.